Dental Practice Owners Over 50: How the 2027 Roth Catch-Up Rule Changes Your 401(k) and Payroll
2026-11-17 · 5 min read · 401k catch-up
Dental practice owners over 50: your 401(k) catch-up may have to go Roth in 2027. Here is how to check your wages, your plan, and your payroll before January.
A quick test before you read further
If you own a dental practice and you are 50 or older, open your payroll software and find one number: your year-to-date Social Security wages from the practice for 2026. On a W-2, that figure shows up in box 3. That single number decides how your 401(k) catch-up contributions work in 2027.
Here is the bottom line. Starting with 2027, if your prior-year wages from the practice were above the IRS wage threshold for the Roth catch-up rule, your catch-up dollars must go in as Roth, meaning after-tax. Your catch-up still works. It just works differently, and your plan and your payroll both need to be ready before the first paycheck in January.
Many owners are rearview savers. They set their deferrals years ago and let payroll run on autopilot. This rule rewards forward planners: the owners who check the setup in the fall instead of finding a problem on a pay stub in February.
What changes, in plain English
A catch-up contribution is the extra amount the tax code lets you put into your 401(k) once you turn 50, on top of the regular limit. For 2026, the regular employee deferral limit is $24,500. The catch-up is $8,000 if you are 50 to 59 or 64 and older, and $11,250 if you are 60 to 63. These limits are set each year, so we confirm them with you annually.
Until now, most owners made catch-up contributions pre-tax. That lowers this year's taxable income, and you pay tax later when you withdraw. A Roth contribution works the other way around. You get no deduction today, but the money grows tax-free and qualified withdrawals come out tax-free.
A federal retirement law passed in 2022 requires higher earners to make catch-ups as Roth. The IRS's final rules apply starting with 2027. Some plans began applying the requirement in 2026 under a good-faith transition, so ask your provider how your plan is handling this year too.
Only the catch-up changes. Your regular deferrals up to $24,500 can stay pre-tax, and employer profit sharing contributions are not affected.
Steps 1 and 2: Check your wages and your plan
The rule looks at last year's Social Security wages from the employer that sponsors the plan. In practice, that means your 2026 W-2 from the practice decides how your 2027 catch-up works. Compare that number to the IRS wage threshold for the Roth catch-up rule. The threshold is indexed each year, and we confirm the current figure with you.
If your practice is taxed as an S corporation, your salary counts toward that number. Your distributions do not. That gives your salary decision a second job. Be careful about cutting salary just to stay under the line, though. Your salary still has to be reasonable for the work you do, and a lower salary can also shrink how much you and the practice can contribute to the plan. If your practice is set up as a sole proprietorship or a partnership, you may not have W-2 wages from it at all, and the rule applies differently. We check which camp you are in.
Next, confirm your 401(k) offers a Roth option. This matters more than it sounds. If your wages are over the threshold and your plan has no Roth feature, you may not be able to make catch-up contributions at all. Ask your plan provider whether a Roth feature is already in the plan document or whether the plan needs an amendment before 2027.
Then look beyond yourself. Associate dentists, a long-tenured office manager or senior hygienists over 50 could also cross the threshold. Your plan has to treat them correctly too.
Step 3: Update payroll before the first 2027 run
Even with the right plan document, the dollars only land in the right place if payroll sends them there. Your payroll provider has to route catch-up contributions to Roth for anyone over the threshold. That takes coordination between payroll and your plan's recordkeeper.
Three questions to ask your provider this fall. How will you flag employees who were over the threshold last year? Will catch-up dollars switch to Roth automatically once someone reaches the $24,500 regular limit? What is your cutoff for setup changes before the first January payroll?
Side by side, the difference looks like this. A pre-tax catch-up lowers this year's tax, grows tax-deferred, and is taxed when you withdraw. A Roth catch-up gives no deduction now, grows tax-free, and comes out tax-free when the withdrawal is qualified, which generally means you are at least 59½ and the Roth account has been open at least five years.
Step 4: Rerun the tax math
Here is a simple example. Say you make an $8,000 catch-up contribution and your federal tax rate is 35%. Made pre-tax, it lowers that year's federal tax by about $2,800. Made as Roth, you pay that $2,800 now, and qualified withdrawals later are tax-free. If you are 60 to 63, an $11,250 catch-up at the same 35% rate means about $3,937 in federal tax paid now instead of later.
That trade can work in your favor, especially if you expect a high income in retirement or want some tax-free money to draw from alongside pre-tax savings. But it also changes your cash needs this year. Your withholding or estimated payments may need to go up so April does not bring a surprise.
This is where we look at the whole picture: your salary, your profit sharing, your spouse's income and your household plan together. The goal is a catch-up strategy that fits, not just one that complies.
Your catch-up still works. Set it up on purpose.
Nothing about this rule takes the catch-up away from you if your plan is ready. What it removes is the option to ignore it. Check your wages, your plan and your payroll now, so the first paycheck in January is set up right.
This article is general education, not individualized tax, legal or investment advice. Your wages, entity type and plan document all affect how the rule applies to you, so we review those details with you directly.
Key takeaways
- Starting with 2027, catch-up contributions for owners whose prior-year practice wages exceed the IRS threshold must go in as Roth.
- Your 2026 Social Security wages from the practice (W-2 box 3) decide how your 2027 catch-up works. S corporation salary counts, distributions do not.
- If your plan has no Roth option, higher earners may lose catch-up contributions entirely, so confirm the plan document now.
- Regular deferrals up to $24,500 can stay pre-tax. Only the catch-up portion ($8,000, or $11,250 at ages 60 to 63) changes.
- Paying tax now on a Roth catch-up changes your cash needs and estimated payments, so rerun your numbers before January.
If you own a dental practice and you are over 50, let's check your wages, your plan document and your payroll setup together before the first 2027 paycheck. Our team handles the coordination with your plan provider and reruns your tax math across your salary, profit sharing and household. Pay Less. Keep More. Build Wealth. Reach out to Eiduk Tax & Wealth to schedule your review.